{ "checklist": [ { "evidence": [ { "artifact_path_count": 20, "artifact_paths_exist": true, "child_statuses": { "bd-h66tp.1": "closed", "bd-h66tp.2": "closed", "bd-h66tp.3": "closed", "bd-h66tp.4": "closed", "bd-h66tp.5": "closed", "bd-h66tp.6": "closed", "bd-h66tp.7": "closed" }, "close_reasons": { "bd-h66tp.1": "Completed: deterministic compaction admission decisions now gate background starts with reason coverage and proof evidence.", "bd-h66tp.2": "Completed: huge built-in tool outputs now spill into bounded session-scoped artifacts with compact references, degraded persistence markers, and session JSONL coverage.", "bd-h66tp.3": "Completed provider routing evidence with fail-closed metrics, cost hints, user override evidence, JSON projection, and TUI regression coverage.", "bd-h66tp.4": "Completed scheduler fairness replay coverage for hostcall, timer, stream, and event storms.", "bd-h66tp.5": "Completed: large-session TUI frame-budget telemetry now emits structured redaction-safe snapshots and covers conversation, tool preview, model selector, branch picker, and tree navigation regressions.", "bd-h66tp.6": "Completed: cancellation cleanup evidence is structured and covered by focused tests.", "bd-h66tp.7": "Completed: offline extension safety provenance is exposed on search/info/install/list surfaces with redacted provenance tests." }, "commit_check_source": "git_cat_file", "commits": [ "d9cfaa66073e0b1d27ccfe2235f0916007c61f7f", "547302f93977849b0f02b19e1f70a9127a154922", "aa5f8bc5183e862dd7d63c2b4524f367776909de", "97cda5eb6eb0446c6e4c7fb8020d891135ae1a6c", "c34a29b3823280198afce8dc850a77f4773b28aa", "09c4d9e02c80ea352f783f69d4e2a774bf21e4bf", "a82551dccb31a478a398665b7843d0afd118d13e" ], "commits_present": true, "path": ".beads/issues.jsonl" } ], "id": "child_beads_closed", "issue": null, "requirement": "All third-wave runtime-intelligence child Beads are closed and mapped to concrete artifacts.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "src/compaction_worker.rs" }, { "path": "docs/evidence/compaction-admission-proof.json" } ], "id": "compaction_admission", "issue": null, "requirement": "Memory-aware compaction admission is deterministic, reason-coded, and backed by proof evidence.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "src/tools.rs" }, { "path": "src/session.rs" }, { "path": "src/agent.rs" } ], "id": "tool_output_artifacts", "issue": null, "requirement": "Huge built-in tool outputs spill into bounded session artifacts instead of unbounded provider-visible payloads.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "src/model_routing.rs" }, { "path": "src/model_selector.rs" }, { "path": "src/interactive/model_selector_ui.rs" } ], "id": "provider_routing", "issue": null, "requirement": "Provider/model routing evidence exposes latency, errors, staleness, cost hints, and user override posture without secrets.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "src/scheduler.rs" } ], "id": "scheduler_fairness", "issue": null, "requirement": "Extension scheduler replay proves hostcall, timer, stream, and event storms remain ordered and non-starving.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "src/interactive/perf.rs" }, { "path": "tests/tui_state.rs" }, { "path": "docs/evidence/large-session-tui-frame-budget.json" } ], "id": "frame_budget", "issue": null, "requirement": "Large-session TUI frame-budget telemetry is redaction-safe and covers conversation, tool preview, model, branch, and tree surfaces.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "src/tools.rs" }, { "path": "src/agent.rs" }, { "path": "docs/evidence/cancellation-cleanup-proof.json" } ], "id": "cancellation_cleanup", "issue": null, "requirement": "Long-running tool and extension cancellation leaves structured evidence and avoids late-success records.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "src/extension_index.rs" }, { "path": "src/main.rs" } ], "id": "extension_safety_provenance", "issue": null, "requirement": "Offline extension search/info/install surfaces expose source, license, category, capability, risk, and freshness provenance.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "README.md" }, { "path": "docs/contracts/runtime-intelligence-closeout-gate-contract.json" }, { "path": "docs/evidence/runtime-intelligence-closeout-gate.json" }, { "path": "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" } ], "id": "docs_and_evidence", "issue": null, "requirement": "Runtime-intelligence operator evidence is linked without promoting advisory evidence into release or drop-in claims.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "evidence": [ { "path": ".beads/issues.jsonl" } ], "id": "beads_are_source_of_truth", "requirement": "Beads record child status, close reasons, and final-gate ownership.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "role": "coordination", "source": "Agent Mail" } ], "id": "agent_mail_is_coordination_only", "requirement": "Agent Mail reservations and messages are coordination signals, not implementation proof.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" } ], "id": "read_only_gate", "requirement": "The closeout gate inspects already-captured artifacts and does not mutate runtime sources.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "required_command_fragment": "rch exec --" } ], "id": "rch_required_for_heavy_cargo", "requirement": "Heavy Cargo gates must prove RCH execution.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "command": "ubs --staged --only=rust ." } ], "id": "staged_ubs_required", "requirement": "The staged UBS gate remains mandatory before the closeout commit.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "command": "./scripts/reconcile_beads_ledger.sh" } ], "id": "beads_ledger_required", "requirement": "Beads ledger reconciliation remains mandatory before the closeout commit.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "claim_authorized": false } ], "id": "no_release_or_dropin_claims", "requirement": "Runtime-intelligence closeout is advisory prompt-to-artifact evidence only.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "closeout_replaces_source_artifacts": false } ], "id": "closeout_does_not_replace_child_artifacts", "requirement": "Passing closeout does not replace child tests, evidence, Beads, git, RCH, UBS, or CI.", "status": "pass" } ], "id": "source_boundaries", "issue": null, "requirement": "Closeout source boundaries preserve Beads, Agent Mail, RCH, UBS, ledger, CI, child evidence, and claim-integrity authorities.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "child_commits": [ "d9cfaa66073e0b1d27ccfe2235f0916007c61f7f", "547302f93977849b0f02b19e1f70a9127a154922", "aa5f8bc5183e862dd7d63c2b4524f367776909de", "97cda5eb6eb0446c6e4c7fb8020d891135ae1a6c", "c34a29b3823280198afce8dc850a77f4773b28aa", "09c4d9e02c80ea352f783f69d4e2a774bf21e4bf", "a82551dccb31a478a398665b7843d0afd118d13e" ], "head_before_closeout_commit": "c34a29b3823280198afce8dc850a77f4773b28aa", "origin_legacy_mirror_before_closeout_commit": "c34a29b3823280198afce8dc850a77f4773b28aa", "origin_main_before_closeout_commit": "c34a29b3823280198afce8dc850a77f4773b28aa", "pushed_remote_refs_equal_head": true } ], "id": "pushed_commits", "issue": null, "requirement": "All implementation child commits are already pushed to origin/main and legacy origin/master before final closeout generation.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "heavy_cargo_uses_rch": true, "provided_quality_gates": [ { "command": "python3 -m py_compile scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py", "id": "py_compile", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test", "id": "runpack_self_test", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "python3 -m json.tool docs/contracts/runtime-intelligence-closeout-gate-contract.json", "id": "json_contracts", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "RCH_VISIBILITY=verbose rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/tmp cargo test --test runtime_intelligence_closeout_gate_contract -- --nocapture", "id": "runtime_intelligence_closeout_gate_contract_rch", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "RCH_VISIBILITY=verbose rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/tmp cargo fmt --check", "id": "cargo_fmt", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "git diff --check", "id": "git_diff_check", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "RCH_VISIBILITY=verbose rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/tmp cargo check --all-targets", "id": "cargo_check_all_targets_rch", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "RCH_VISIBILITY=verbose rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/tmp cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings", "id": "cargo_clippy_all_targets_rch", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "timeout 120s ubs --staged --only=rust .; python3 scripts/check_ubs_staged_delta.py if baseline noisy", "id": "staged_ubs", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "./scripts/reconcile_beads_ledger.sh", "id": "beads_ledger_reconcile", "status": "pass" } ], "required_quality_gates": [ "py_compile", "runpack_self_test", "json_contracts", "runtime_intelligence_closeout_gate_contract_rch", "cargo_fmt", "git_diff_check", "cargo_check_all_targets_rch", "cargo_clippy_all_targets_rch", "staged_ubs", "beads_ledger_reconcile" ] } ], "id": "quality_gates", "issue": null, "requirement": "Required closeout quality gates passed, with every Cargo/Rust validation gate run through RCH.", "status": "pass" } ], "child_artifact_map": [ { "bead_id": "bd-h66tp.1", "close_reason": "Completed: deterministic compaction admission decisions now gate background starts with reason coverage and proof evidence.", "code_paths": [ "src/agent.rs", "src/compaction_worker.rs" ], "commit": "d9cfaa66073e0b1d27ccfe2235f0916007c61f7f", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "docs/evidence/compaction-admission-proof.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "src/compaction_worker.rs" ], "title": "Add memory-aware compaction admission and proof evidence", "validation_commands": [ "rch exec -- cargo test --lib compaction_admission -- --nocapture", "rch exec -- cargo check --all-targets", "rch exec -- cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-h66tp.2", "close_reason": "Completed: huge built-in tool outputs now spill into bounded session-scoped artifacts with compact references, degraded persistence markers, and session JSONL coverage.", "code_paths": [ "src/agent.rs", "src/session.rs", "src/tools.rs" ], "commit": "547302f93977849b0f02b19e1f70a9127a154922", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ ".beads/issues.jsonl" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "src/session.rs", "src/tools.rs" ], "title": "Spill huge tool outputs into bounded session artifacts", "validation_commands": [ "rch exec -- cargo test --lib artifact -- --nocapture", "rch exec -- cargo check --all-targets", "rch exec -- cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-h66tp.3", "close_reason": "Completed provider routing evidence with fail-closed metrics, cost hints, user override evidence, JSON projection, and TUI regression coverage.", "code_paths": [ "src/interactive/model_selector_ui.rs", "src/model_routing.rs", "src/model_selector.rs" ], "commit": "aa5f8bc5183e862dd7d63c2b4524f367776909de", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ ".beads/issues.jsonl" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "src/model_routing.rs", "src/model_selector.rs" ], "title": "Add provider latency and cost circuit-breaker routing evidence", "validation_commands": [ "rch exec -- cargo test --lib model_routing -- --nocapture", "rch exec -- cargo test --test tui_state routing -- --nocapture", "rch exec -- cargo check --all-targets", "rch exec -- cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-h66tp.4", "close_reason": "Completed scheduler fairness replay coverage for hostcall, timer, stream, and event storms.", "code_paths": [ "src/scheduler.rs" ], "commit": "97cda5eb6eb0446c6e4c7fb8020d891135ae1a6c", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ ".beads/issues.jsonl" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "src/scheduler.rs" ], "title": "Replay extension scheduler fairness under hostcall and timer storms", "validation_commands": [ "rch exec -- cargo test --lib scheduler_fairness_replay -- --nocapture", "rch exec -- cargo check --all-targets", "rch exec -- cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-h66tp.5", "close_reason": "Completed: large-session TUI frame-budget telemetry now emits structured redaction-safe snapshots and covers conversation, tool preview, model selector, branch picker, and tree navigation regressions.", "code_paths": [ "src/interactive.rs", "src/interactive/perf.rs" ], "commit": "c34a29b3823280198afce8dc850a77f4773b28aa", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "docs/evidence/large-session-tui-frame-budget.json", "docs/tui.md" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "tests/tui_state.rs" ], "title": "Add large-session TUI frame-budget telemetry and regression coverage", "validation_commands": [ "rch exec -- cargo test -p pi_agent_rust --test tui_state frame_budget -- --nocapture", "rch exec -- cargo check --all-targets", "rch exec -- cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-h66tp.6", "close_reason": "Completed: cancellation cleanup evidence is structured and covered by focused tests.", "code_paths": [ "src/agent.rs", "src/extensions_js.rs", "src/interactive/commands.rs", "src/tools.rs" ], "commit": "09c4d9e02c80ea352f783f69d4e2a774bf21e4bf", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "docs/evidence/cancellation-cleanup-proof.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "src/agent.rs", "src/tools.rs" ], "title": "Prove cooperative cancellation cleanup for long-running tools and extensions", "validation_commands": [ "rch exec -- cargo test --lib abort_during_tool_execution_records_aborted_tool_result -- --nocapture", "rch exec -- cargo test --lib test_bash_timeout_includes_cancellation_details -- --nocapture", "rch exec -- cargo check --all-targets", "rch exec -- cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-h66tp.7", "close_reason": "Completed: offline extension safety provenance is exposed on search/info/install/list surfaces with redacted provenance tests.", "code_paths": [ "src/extension_index.rs", "src/main.rs" ], "commit": "a82551dccb31a478a398665b7843d0afd118d13e", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ ".beads/issues.jsonl" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "src/extension_index.rs" ], "title": "Add offline extension safety provenance to search and install surfaces", "validation_commands": [ "rch exec -- cargo test --lib extension_safety_provenance -- --nocapture", "rch exec -- cargo check --all-targets", "rch exec -- cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings" ] } ], "claim_boundaries": { "allowed_claim": "advisory prompt-to-artifact runtime-intelligence closeout evidence only", "closeout_replaces_source_artifacts": false, "runtime_intelligence_is_release_performance_evidence": false, "strict_dropin_or_release_claim_authorized": false }, "decision": "close_final_gate_and_parent_epic", "epic_can_close_after_this_commit": true, "final_gate_bead": { "assignee": "AmberOsprey", "id": "bd-h66tp.8", "status": "in_progress" }, "follow_up_beads": [], "follow_up_required": false, "generated_at": "2026-05-16T05:51:14.843753+00:00", "known_limitations": [ "Agent Mail is coordination evidence only; reservations/messages do not replace Beads, source review, or validation gates.", "Runtime-intelligence closeout is not release performance evidence, capacity evidence, benchmark evidence, or strict drop-in certification evidence.", "A passing closeout gate is not permission to skip source-specific tests, RCH, cargo fmt, cargo check, cargo clippy, staged UBS, Beads ledger reconciliation, CI, or push verification." ], "missing_checks": [], "parent_epic": { "id": "bd-h66tp", "status": "deferred", "title": "Swarm-scale runtime intelligence third-wave roadmap" }, "purpose": "prompt_to_artifact_runtime_intelligence_closeout_gate_not_source_of_truth", "quality_gate_results": [ { "command": "python3 -m py_compile scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py", "id": "py_compile", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test", "id": "runpack_self_test", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "python3 -m json.tool docs/contracts/runtime-intelligence-closeout-gate-contract.json", "id": "json_contracts", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "RCH_VISIBILITY=verbose rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/tmp cargo test --test runtime_intelligence_closeout_gate_contract -- --nocapture", "id": "runtime_intelligence_closeout_gate_contract_rch", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "RCH_VISIBILITY=verbose rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/tmp cargo fmt --check", "id": "cargo_fmt", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "git diff --check", "id": "git_diff_check", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "RCH_VISIBILITY=verbose rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/tmp cargo check --all-targets", "id": "cargo_check_all_targets_rch", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "RCH_VISIBILITY=verbose rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo/amberosprey_bd_h66tp_8/tmp cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings", "id": "cargo_clippy_all_targets_rch", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "timeout 120s ubs --staged --only=rust .; python3 scripts/check_ubs_staged_delta.py if baseline noisy", "id": "staged_ubs", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "./scripts/reconcile_beads_ledger.sh", "id": "beads_ledger_reconcile", "status": "pass" } ], "remaining_follow_ups": [], "required_checks": [ "child_beads_closed", "compaction_admission", "tool_output_artifacts", "provider_routing", "scheduler_fairness", "frame_budget", "cancellation_cleanup", "extension_safety_provenance", "docs_and_evidence", "source_boundaries", "pushed_commits", "quality_gates" ], "schema": "pi.runtime_intelligence.closeout_gate.v1", "source_boundary_checks": [ { "evidence": [ { "path": ".beads/issues.jsonl" } ], "id": "beads_are_source_of_truth", "requirement": "Beads record child status, close reasons, and final-gate ownership.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "role": "coordination", "source": "Agent Mail" } ], "id": "agent_mail_is_coordination_only", "requirement": "Agent Mail reservations and messages are coordination signals, not implementation proof.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" } ], "id": "read_only_gate", "requirement": "The closeout gate inspects already-captured artifacts and does not mutate runtime sources.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "required_command_fragment": "rch exec --" } ], "id": "rch_required_for_heavy_cargo", "requirement": "Heavy Cargo gates must prove RCH execution.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "command": "ubs --staged --only=rust ." } ], "id": "staged_ubs_required", "requirement": "The staged UBS gate remains mandatory before the closeout commit.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "command": "./scripts/reconcile_beads_ledger.sh" } ], "id": "beads_ledger_required", "requirement": "Beads ledger reconciliation remains mandatory before the closeout commit.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "claim_authorized": false } ], "id": "no_release_or_dropin_claims", "requirement": "Runtime-intelligence closeout is advisory prompt-to-artifact evidence only.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "closeout_replaces_source_artifacts": false } ], "id": "closeout_does_not_replace_child_artifacts", "requirement": "Passing closeout does not replace child tests, evidence, Beads, git, RCH, UBS, or CI.", "status": "pass" } ], "status": "pass" }