{ "checklist": [ { "evidence": [ { "child_statuses": { "bd-63x3v.9.1": "closed", "bd-63x3v.9.2": "closed", "bd-63x3v.9.3": "closed", "bd-63x3v.9.4": "closed", "bd-63x3v.9.5": "closed", "bd-63x3v.9.6": "closed", "bd-63x3v.9.7": "closed", "bd-63x3v.9.8": "closed", "bd-63x3v.9.9": "closed" }, "close_reasons": { "bd-63x3v.9.1": "Completed: added RCH worker workspace-shadow classifier and runpack failure-action coverage for stale parent-workspace cargo failures.", "bd-63x3v.9.2": "Completed: runpack/autopilot degraded Agent Mail posture now distinguishes transport and semantic readiness and surfaces Beads active ownership evidence for soft locks.", "bd-63x3v.9.3": "Completed validation proof replay ledger for cargo/script/UBS/Beads gates with coverage authority, fail-closed claimed-path mismatch handling, and blocker fixtures for unrelated worktree plus RCH workspace shadow.", "bd-63x3v.9.4": "Completed read-only temp artifact inventory with explicit no-delete cleanup boundaries, stable fixtures, and runpack/runbook contract coverage.", "bd-63x3v.9.5": "Implemented deterministic stale in-progress bead report with dirty worktree, recent commit, and degraded coordination evidence handling", "bd-63x3v.9.6": "Completed no-mock degraded-coordination runpack E2E with real temp Beads inputs, Agent Mail semantic failure fixture, RCH workspace-shadow blocker, degraded validation assertions, and no-delete evidence.", "bd-63x3v.9.7": "Completed deterministic cgroup/NUMA/local-build/RCH queue swarm validation budget model with Doctor budget explanations and replay fixtures.", "bd-63x3v.9.8": "Completed provider/RPC/TUI backpressure budget contract with read-only aggregator, contract, and checked-in evidence", "bd-63x3v.9.9": "Completed operator explanation layer for stale evidence, missing artifacts, RCH failures, dirty worktree conflicts, and Agent Mail degradation with claim-integrity fixtures" }, "path": ".beads/issues.jsonl" } ], "id": "child_beads_closed", "issue": null, "requirement": "All sixth-wave validation-hardening child Beads are closed before closeout.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "artifact_paths_exist": true, "child_artifact_map": [ { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.1", "claim_boundary_text": "RCH workspace-shadow detection does not mutate workers, cancel jobs, or claim pi_agent_rust failed to compile when worker checkout scope is wrong.", "close_reason": "Completed: added RCH worker workspace-shadow classifier and runpack failure-action coverage for stale parent-workspace cargo failures.", "code_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py", "scripts/generate_maintenance_dashboard.py" ], "commit": "76edc24d8c5356021f67e9eede16e8ec26c961dd", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py", "scripts/generate_maintenance_dashboard.py" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "title": "Detect RCH remote workspace shadow failures before cargo gates", "validation_commands": [ "python3 -m py_compile scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py scripts/generate_maintenance_dashboard.py", "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.2", "claim_boundary_text": "Degraded Agent Mail posture recommends Beads soft locks but does not repair, mutate, or replace Agent Mail state.", "close_reason": "Completed: runpack/autopilot degraded Agent Mail posture now distinguishes transport and semantic readiness and surfaces Beads active ownership evidence for soft locks.", "code_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "commit": "c86034884e8187b53c65f25977c699848a5d6b5b", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/autopilot_plan_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/complete_runpack_projection.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/autopilot_plan_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/complete_runpack_projection.json" ], "title": "Report Agent Mail degraded-mode Beads soft-lock posture in swarm preflight", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.3", "claim_boundary_text": "Validation proof replay ledger records command authority and blockers but does not make uncovered validation green.", "close_reason": "Completed validation proof replay ledger for cargo/script/UBS/Beads gates with coverage authority, fail-closed claimed-path mismatch handling, and blocker fixtures for unrelated worktree plus RCH workspace shadow.", "code_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "commit": "5e61b18a6eba6f39d05c6325219ce34f3d12579f", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "docs/contracts/remote-validation-proof-ledger-contract.json", "docs/swarm-operations-runbook.md", "tests/golden_corpus/remote_validation_proof_ledger/examples.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/remote_validation_proof_ledger/examples.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/complete_runpack_projection.json" ], "title": "Build validation proof replay ledger for cargo and script gates", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test", "python3 -m json.tool docs/contracts/remote-validation-proof-ledger-contract.json" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.4", "claim_boundary_text": "Temp artifact inventory is read-only and does not authorize file or directory deletion without operator approval.", "close_reason": "Completed read-only temp artifact inventory with explicit no-delete cleanup boundaries, stable fixtures, and runpack/runbook contract coverage.", "code_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "commit": "7895a1a6f9d38015792d8ec26bd061ff8f668443", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "docs/contracts/swarm-operator-runpack-contract.json", "docs/swarm-operations-runbook.md", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/complete_runpack_projection.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/complete_runpack_projection.json" ], "title": "Track swarm temp artifacts and cleanup permission boundaries", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test", "python3 -m json.tool docs/contracts/swarm-operator-runpack-contract.json" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.5", "claim_boundary_text": "Stale in-progress bead heuristics emit review checklists and do not auto-reopen or steal active work.", "close_reason": "Implemented deterministic stale in-progress bead report with dirty worktree, recent commit, and degraded coordination evidence handling", "code_paths": [ "scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py" ], "commit": "d044c04784293ae9b351ddb45bcd85d40ff3b828", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/complete_report_projection.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/complete_report_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/hostcall_fallback_heavy_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/hostcall_missing_fields_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/hostcall_missing_telemetry_projection.json" ], "title": "Add stale in-progress bead heuristic report with safe reopen checklist", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py --self-test" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.6", "claim_boundary_text": "Degraded-coordination E2E evidence proves handoff behavior only and does not mark validation infrastructure healthy.", "close_reason": "Completed no-mock degraded-coordination runpack E2E with real temp Beads inputs, Agent Mail semantic failure fixture, RCH workspace-shadow blocker, degraded validation assertions, and no-delete evidence.", "code_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "commit": "776e60465fd3aafeedc664f4d001a473540c9934", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "README.md", "docs/swarm-operations-runbook.md" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "title": "Add no-mock degraded-coordination swarm runpack E2E", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.7", "claim_boundary_text": "Swarm resource budget recommendations are advisory and do not create release-facing performance or capacity claims.", "close_reason": "Completed deterministic cgroup/NUMA/local-build/RCH queue swarm validation budget model with Doctor budget explanations and replay fixtures.", "code_paths": [ "src/doctor.rs" ], "commit": "81a7d4dd479ac6efa85ca462078ef1d9850c0668", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "README.md" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "src/doctor.rs", "tests/doctor_swarm_temp_dir_json.rs" ], "title": "Model cgroup and NUMA-aware swarm validation budgets", "validation_commands": [ "rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo//target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo//tmp cargo test swarm_resource_preflight -- --nocapture", "rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo//target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo//tmp cargo check --all-targets", "rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo//target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo//tmp cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.8", "claim_boundary_text": "Provider/RPC/TUI backpressure budget contract aggregates existing evidence and does not duplicate or replace pressure tests.", "close_reason": "Completed provider/RPC/TUI backpressure budget contract with read-only aggregator, contract, and checked-in evidence", "code_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "commit": "219884dcce3a5cd622d87ca24fbcafdc593f8dc8", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "docs/contracts/provider-rpc-tui-backpressure-budget-contract.json", "docs/evidence/provider-rpc-tui-backpressure-budget-contract.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "title": "Unify provider RPC TUI backpressure evidence into one budget contract", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --run-backpressure-budget-contract --print-backpressure-budget-contract", "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.9", "claim_boundary_text": "Operator explanations summarize blockers and next safe actions but do not make stale, missing, or degraded evidence green.", "close_reason": "Completed operator explanation layer for stale evidence, missing artifacts, RCH failures, dirty worktree conflicts, and Agent Mail degradation with claim-integrity fixtures", "code_paths": [ "scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py" ], "commit": "416af8fbd0239c9afce6bfc1e186eea8c4d1ebab", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/complete_report_projection.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/complete_report_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/hostcall_fallback_heavy_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/hostcall_missing_fields_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/hostcall_missing_telemetry_projection.json" ], "title": "Add operator explainability for stale evidence and validation blockers", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py --self-test" ] } ], "commits_present": true, "weak_child_rows": [] } ], "id": "child_artifact_mapping", "issue": null, "requirement": "Every sixth-wave child bead maps to pushed commits, source paths, validation commands, and claim-boundary text.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" }, { "path": "scripts/generate_maintenance_dashboard.py" } ], "id": "rch_workspace_shadow_detector", "issue": null, "requirement": "RCH worker workspace-shadow failures are classified before cargo results are trusted.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" } ], "id": "agent_mail_beads_soft_lock", "issue": null, "requirement": "Agent Mail semantic corruption surfaces Beads soft-lock fallback without blocking work.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" }, { "path": "docs/contracts/remote-validation-proof-ledger-contract.json" } ], "id": "validation_proof_replay_ledger", "issue": null, "requirement": "Cargo and script validation proofs record command, runner, coverage, result, and blocker authority.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" }, { "path": "docs/swarm-operations-runbook.md" } ], "id": "temp_artifact_inventory", "issue": null, "requirement": "Swarm temp artifacts are inventoried with explicit no-delete policy boundaries.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py" } ], "id": "stale_claim_heuristics", "issue": null, "requirement": "Stale in-progress bead reporting emits review checklists instead of automatic reopen actions.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" }, { "path": "README.md" } ], "id": "degraded_coordination_e2e", "issue": null, "requirement": "No-mock degraded-coordination E2E evidence covers Beads soft locks, degraded validation, and no-delete output.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "src/doctor.rs" }, { "path": "tests/doctor_swarm_temp_dir_json.rs" } ], "id": "resource_budget_model", "issue": null, "requirement": "Doctor swarm resource preflight consumes cgroup, NUMA, local build pressure, and RCH queue posture with explanations.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "docs/contracts/provider-rpc-tui-backpressure-budget-contract.json" }, { "path": "docs/evidence/provider-rpc-tui-backpressure-budget-contract.json" } ], "id": "backpressure_budget_contract", "issue": null, "requirement": "Provider, RPC, and TUI pressure evidence is normalized into one read-only budget contract.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "path": "scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py" } ], "id": "operator_explanations", "issue": null, "requirement": "Validation blockers map to stable categories, explanations, affected artifacts, and next safe actions.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "boundary": "Beads issue state and close reasons remain the work ledger.", "evidence": [ ".beads/issues.jsonl" ], "id": "beads_are_source_of_truth", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "Agent Mail coordinates ownership but does not replace Beads, git, source inspection, or validation evidence.", "evidence": [ "AGENTS.md" ], "id": "agent_mail_is_coordination_only", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "The sixth-wave closeout gate summarizes existing evidence and does not mutate runtime sources.", "evidence": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "id": "read_only_gate", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "Heavy Cargo validation evidence must prove RCH execution.", "evidence": [ "AGENTS.md" ], "id": "rch_required_for_heavy_cargo", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "Staged UBS remains mandatory before the closeout commit.", "evidence": [ "AGENTS.md" ], "id": "staged_ubs_required", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "Beads ledger reconciliation remains mandatory before closeout.", "evidence": [ "scripts/reconcile_beads_ledger.sh" ], "id": "beads_ledger_required", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "Sixth-wave validation hardening closeout evidence is advisory and does not authorize release, benchmark, capacity, performance, or strict drop-in claims.", "evidence": [ "docs/contracts/dropin-certification-contract.json", "docs/evidence/dropin-certification-verdict.json" ], "id": "no_release_or_dropin_claims", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "The gate must not mutate Agent Mail storage, RCH worker state, installed extensions, user config, git refs, or temp artifacts.", "evidence": [ "AGENTS.md", "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "id": "no_mail_or_rch_mutation", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "The closeout gate summarizes child evidence and does not replace source tests, contracts, Beads, pushed commits, RCH, UBS, or CI.", "evidence": [ "docs/evidence/sixth-wave-validation-hardening-closeout-gate.json" ], "id": "closeout_does_not_replace_child_artifacts", "status": "pass" } ], "id": "source_boundaries", "issue": null, "requirement": "Closeout source boundaries preserve Beads, Agent Mail, RCH, UBS, ledger, child-artifact, no-delete, and release-claim authorities.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "child_commits": [ "76edc24d8c5356021f67e9eede16e8ec26c961dd", "c86034884e8187b53c65f25977c699848a5d6b5b", "5e61b18a6eba6f39d05c6325219ce34f3d12579f", "7895a1a6f9d38015792d8ec26bd061ff8f668443", "d044c04784293ae9b351ddb45bcd85d40ff3b828", "776e60465fd3aafeedc664f4d001a473540c9934", "81a7d4dd479ac6efa85ca462078ef1d9850c0668", "219884dcce3a5cd622d87ca24fbcafdc593f8dc8", "416af8fbd0239c9afce6bfc1e186eea8c4d1ebab" ], "head_before_closeout_commit": "81a7d4dd479ac6efa85ca462078ef1d9850c0668", "origin_legacy_mirror_before_closeout_commit": "81a7d4dd479ac6efa85ca462078ef1d9850c0668", "origin_main_before_closeout_commit": "81a7d4dd479ac6efa85ca462078ef1d9850c0668", "pushed_remote_refs_equal_head": true } ], "id": "pushed_commits", "issue": null, "requirement": "All prerequisite child commits are pushed to origin/main and legacy origin/master before final closeout generation.", "status": "pass" }, { "evidence": [ { "heavy_cargo_required_for_closeout_script": false, "provided_quality_gates": [ { "command": "python3 -m py_compile scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py", "id": "py_compile", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test", "id": "runpack_self_test", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "python3 scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py --self-test", "id": "claim_readiness_self_test", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "python3 -m json.tool docs/contracts/sixth-wave-validation-hardening-closeout-gate-contract.json", "id": "json_contracts", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "git diff --check", "id": "git_diff_check", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "timeout 60s ubs --staged --only=rust .", "id": "staged_ubs", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "./scripts/reconcile_beads_ledger.sh", "id": "beads_ledger_reconcile", "status": "pass" } ], "required_quality_gates": [ "py_compile", "runpack_self_test", "claim_readiness_self_test", "json_contracts", "git_diff_check", "staged_ubs", "beads_ledger_reconcile" ] } ], "id": "quality_gates", "issue": null, "requirement": "Required closeout quality gates passed for scripts, contracts, UBS, and Beads ledger.", "status": "pass" } ], "child_artifact_map": [ { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.1", "claim_boundary_text": "RCH workspace-shadow detection does not mutate workers, cancel jobs, or claim pi_agent_rust failed to compile when worker checkout scope is wrong.", "close_reason": "Completed: added RCH worker workspace-shadow classifier and runpack failure-action coverage for stale parent-workspace cargo failures.", "code_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py", "scripts/generate_maintenance_dashboard.py" ], "commit": "76edc24d8c5356021f67e9eede16e8ec26c961dd", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py", "scripts/generate_maintenance_dashboard.py" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "title": "Detect RCH remote workspace shadow failures before cargo gates", "validation_commands": [ "python3 -m py_compile scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py scripts/generate_maintenance_dashboard.py", "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.2", "claim_boundary_text": "Degraded Agent Mail posture recommends Beads soft locks but does not repair, mutate, or replace Agent Mail state.", "close_reason": "Completed: runpack/autopilot degraded Agent Mail posture now distinguishes transport and semantic readiness and surfaces Beads active ownership evidence for soft locks.", "code_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "commit": "c86034884e8187b53c65f25977c699848a5d6b5b", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/autopilot_plan_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/complete_runpack_projection.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/autopilot_plan_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/complete_runpack_projection.json" ], "title": "Report Agent Mail degraded-mode Beads soft-lock posture in swarm preflight", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.3", "claim_boundary_text": "Validation proof replay ledger records command authority and blockers but does not make uncovered validation green.", "close_reason": "Completed validation proof replay ledger for cargo/script/UBS/Beads gates with coverage authority, fail-closed claimed-path mismatch handling, and blocker fixtures for unrelated worktree plus RCH workspace shadow.", "code_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "commit": "5e61b18a6eba6f39d05c6325219ce34f3d12579f", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "docs/contracts/remote-validation-proof-ledger-contract.json", "docs/swarm-operations-runbook.md", "tests/golden_corpus/remote_validation_proof_ledger/examples.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/remote_validation_proof_ledger/examples.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/complete_runpack_projection.json" ], "title": "Build validation proof replay ledger for cargo and script gates", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test", "python3 -m json.tool docs/contracts/remote-validation-proof-ledger-contract.json" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.4", "claim_boundary_text": "Temp artifact inventory is read-only and does not authorize file or directory deletion without operator approval.", "close_reason": "Completed read-only temp artifact inventory with explicit no-delete cleanup boundaries, stable fixtures, and runpack/runbook contract coverage.", "code_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "commit": "7895a1a6f9d38015792d8ec26bd061ff8f668443", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "docs/contracts/swarm-operator-runpack-contract.json", "docs/swarm-operations-runbook.md", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/complete_runpack_projection.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_operator_runpack/complete_runpack_projection.json" ], "title": "Track swarm temp artifacts and cleanup permission boundaries", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test", "python3 -m json.tool docs/contracts/swarm-operator-runpack-contract.json" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.5", "claim_boundary_text": "Stale in-progress bead heuristics emit review checklists and do not auto-reopen or steal active work.", "close_reason": "Implemented deterministic stale in-progress bead report with dirty worktree, recent commit, and degraded coordination evidence handling", "code_paths": [ "scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py" ], "commit": "d044c04784293ae9b351ddb45bcd85d40ff3b828", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/complete_report_projection.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/complete_report_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/hostcall_fallback_heavy_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/hostcall_missing_fields_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/hostcall_missing_telemetry_projection.json" ], "title": "Add stale in-progress bead heuristic report with safe reopen checklist", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py --self-test" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.6", "claim_boundary_text": "Degraded-coordination E2E evidence proves handoff behavior only and does not mark validation infrastructure healthy.", "close_reason": "Completed no-mock degraded-coordination runpack E2E with real temp Beads inputs, Agent Mail semantic failure fixture, RCH workspace-shadow blocker, degraded validation assertions, and no-delete evidence.", "code_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "commit": "776e60465fd3aafeedc664f4d001a473540c9934", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "README.md", "docs/swarm-operations-runbook.md" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "title": "Add no-mock degraded-coordination swarm runpack E2E", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.7", "claim_boundary_text": "Swarm resource budget recommendations are advisory and do not create release-facing performance or capacity claims.", "close_reason": "Completed deterministic cgroup/NUMA/local-build/RCH queue swarm validation budget model with Doctor budget explanations and replay fixtures.", "code_paths": [ "src/doctor.rs" ], "commit": "81a7d4dd479ac6efa85ca462078ef1d9850c0668", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "README.md" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "src/doctor.rs", "tests/doctor_swarm_temp_dir_json.rs" ], "title": "Model cgroup and NUMA-aware swarm validation budgets", "validation_commands": [ "rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo//target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo//tmp cargo test swarm_resource_preflight -- --nocapture", "rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo//target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo//tmp cargo check --all-targets", "rch exec -- env CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo//target TMPDIR=/data/tmp/pi_agent_rust_cargo//tmp cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.8", "claim_boundary_text": "Provider/RPC/TUI backpressure budget contract aggregates existing evidence and does not duplicate or replace pressure tests.", "close_reason": "Completed provider/RPC/TUI backpressure budget contract with read-only aggregator, contract, and checked-in evidence", "code_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "commit": "219884dcce3a5cd622d87ca24fbcafdc593f8dc8", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "docs/contracts/provider-rpc-tui-backpressure-budget-contract.json", "docs/evidence/provider-rpc-tui-backpressure-budget-contract.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "title": "Unify provider RPC TUI backpressure evidence into one budget contract", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --run-backpressure-budget-contract --print-backpressure-budget-contract", "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test" ] }, { "bead_id": "bd-63x3v.9.9", "claim_boundary_text": "Operator explanations summarize blockers and next safe actions but do not make stale, missing, or degraded evidence green.", "close_reason": "Completed operator explanation layer for stale evidence, missing artifacts, RCH failures, dirty worktree conflicts, and Agent Mail degradation with claim-integrity fixtures", "code_paths": [ "scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py" ], "commit": "416af8fbd0239c9afce6bfc1e186eea8c4d1ebab", "docs_or_evidence_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/complete_report_projection.json" ], "status": "closed", "test_paths": [ "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/complete_report_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/hostcall_fallback_heavy_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/hostcall_missing_fields_projection.json", "tests/golden_corpus/swarm_claim_readiness/hostcall_missing_telemetry_projection.json" ], "title": "Add operator explainability for stale evidence and validation blockers", "validation_commands": [ "python3 scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py --self-test" ] } ], "claim_boundaries": { "allowed_claim": "advisory sixth-wave validation hardening closeout evidence only", "closeout_authorizes_file_deletion": false, "closeout_mutates_agent_mail_or_rch": false, "closeout_mutates_sources": false, "closeout_replaces_child_artifacts": false, "performance_or_capacity_claim_authorized": false, "strict_dropin_or_release_claim_authorized": false }, "decision": "close_final_gate_and_parent_epic", "epic_can_close_after_this_commit": true, "final_gate_bead": { "assignee": "Codex", "id": "bd-63x3v.9.10", "status": "closed" }, "follow_up_beads": [], "follow_up_required": false, "generated_at": "2026-05-17T04:58:10Z", "known_limitations": [ "Sixth-wave validation hardening closeout evidence is advisory operator evidence only.", "RCH, Agent Mail, Beads, Doctor, runpack, and claim-readiness proofs remain their own sources of truth.", "This closeout does not authorize release, benchmark, capacity, performance, or strict drop-in claims." ], "missing_checks": [], "parent_epic": { "id": "bd-63x3v.9", "status": "closed", "title": "Swarm validation hardening sixth-wave roadmap" }, "purpose": "prompt_to_artifact_sixth_wave_validation_hardening_closeout_gate_not_source_of_truth", "quality_gate_results": [ { "command": "python3 -m py_compile scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py", "id": "py_compile", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "python3 scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py --self-test", "id": "runpack_self_test", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "python3 scripts/report_swarm_claim_readiness.py --self-test", "id": "claim_readiness_self_test", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "python3 -m json.tool docs/contracts/sixth-wave-validation-hardening-closeout-gate-contract.json >/dev/null && python3 -m json.tool docs/evidence/sixth-wave-validation-hardening-closeout-gate.json >/dev/null", "id": "json_contracts", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "git diff --check", "id": "git_diff_check", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "timeout 60s ubs --staged --only=rust .", "id": "staged_ubs", "status": "pass" }, { "command": "./scripts/reconcile_beads_ledger.sh", "id": "beads_ledger_reconcile", "status": "pass" } ], "remaining_follow_ups": [], "required_checks": [ "child_beads_closed", "child_artifact_mapping", "rch_workspace_shadow_detector", "agent_mail_beads_soft_lock", "validation_proof_replay_ledger", "temp_artifact_inventory", "stale_claim_heuristics", "degraded_coordination_e2e", "resource_budget_model", "backpressure_budget_contract", "operator_explanations", "source_boundaries", "pushed_commits", "quality_gates" ], "schema": "pi.swarm.validation_hardening.closeout_gate.v1", "source_boundary_checks": [ { "boundary": "Beads issue state and close reasons remain the work ledger.", "evidence": [ ".beads/issues.jsonl" ], "id": "beads_are_source_of_truth", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "Agent Mail coordinates ownership but does not replace Beads, git, source inspection, or validation evidence.", "evidence": [ "AGENTS.md" ], "id": "agent_mail_is_coordination_only", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "The sixth-wave closeout gate summarizes existing evidence and does not mutate runtime sources.", "evidence": [ "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "id": "read_only_gate", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "Heavy Cargo validation evidence must prove RCH execution.", "evidence": [ "AGENTS.md" ], "id": "rch_required_for_heavy_cargo", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "Staged UBS remains mandatory before the closeout commit.", "evidence": [ "AGENTS.md" ], "id": "staged_ubs_required", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "Beads ledger reconciliation remains mandatory before closeout.", "evidence": [ "scripts/reconcile_beads_ledger.sh" ], "id": "beads_ledger_required", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "Sixth-wave validation hardening closeout evidence is advisory and does not authorize release, benchmark, capacity, performance, or strict drop-in claims.", "evidence": [ "docs/contracts/dropin-certification-contract.json", "docs/evidence/dropin-certification-verdict.json" ], "id": "no_release_or_dropin_claims", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "The gate must not mutate Agent Mail storage, RCH worker state, installed extensions, user config, git refs, or temp artifacts.", "evidence": [ "AGENTS.md", "scripts/build_swarm_operator_runpack.py" ], "id": "no_mail_or_rch_mutation", "status": "pass" }, { "boundary": "The closeout gate summarizes child evidence and does not replace source tests, contracts, Beads, pushed commits, RCH, UBS, or CI.", "evidence": [ "docs/evidence/sixth-wave-validation-hardening-closeout-gate.json" ], "id": "closeout_does_not_replace_child_artifacts", "status": "pass" } ], "status": "pass" }